A Metaphor: Is All the HOOPLA Over "Unsafe" Cosmetics Really True?

If you had a choice between dating a super popular, flashy, charming guy who was suspected of murder, but was out on bail because the jury could not establish proof beyond a reasonable doubt, or dating a "nice boy" from a good family who had a flawless criminal record and gave you everything you could possibly dream of in a relationship... Which guy would you choose? (Hard to decide? What if it was your daughter making the decision...?)